I want to start with an honest admission: the Church has largely failed on the subject of sexuality. Not in one direction — in both. Some parts of the Church have been so loud with condemnation that they drove people away before they could ever be helped. Other parts have been so silent from fear of controversy that they left people standing at the door with genuine questions and got nothing back. Both failures are real. Both have cost real people real harm. And if I am going to write a book on this subject — and I have — then I have to name both failures before I can offer anything constructive.
When Condemnation Replaced Compassion
I have sat with people who told me what it was like to come to a church carrying questions about their sexuality and to be met not with the love of God but with the coldness of religious culture. The message they received — sometimes explicit, sometimes delivered in sideways glances and loaded silence — was that they were somehow beyond the reach of normal grace. That what they were experiencing placed them in a different category of sinner, one that the congregation didn’t quite know what to do with.
This is not faithfulness. It is a failure of pastoral love dressed up as doctrinal conviction. When people leave a church never wanting to return, having concluded from their experience that God views them with contempt rather than compassion, something has gone badly wrong. You cannot communicate the love of God through cruelty. You cannot lead someone to truth through shame. The method contradicts the message. Behind every one of these errors sits the same root: why the church is too afraid to have this conversation at all.
I am not saying — and I want to be clear about this — that the Church should have stopped teaching what the Bible says. I am saying that there is a world of difference between teaching Scripture faithfully with pastoral love and wielding Scripture as a weapon. Jesus made that distinction constantly. The religious leaders of his day were experts at using the law to condemn. He rebuked them for it, not because the law was wrong, but because condemnation was never the law’s purpose. For one reader, honest teaching changed everything — when the Bible finally made sense about sexuality.
When Silence Replaced Truth
The other failure is subtler and, in some ways, more damaging. The Church, frightened of the cultural backlash, the social media storm, the accusation of bigotry, has in many places simply stopped talking about sexuality altogether. The subject has become too hot to handle. Pastors have told me privately that they wouldn’t touch it from the pulpit because they couldn’t afford to lose people over it.
This is what the prophet Jeremiah was addressing when he wrote: “They dress the wound of my people as if it were not serious. ‘Peace, peace,’ they say, when there is no peace.” (Jeremiah 6:14, MEV). The false comfort that says “you’re fine, God accepts you just as you are” — without any engagement with what God actually says about sexuality — is not kindness. It is a dereliction of pastoral duty. A doctor who tells a patient their tumour is nothing to worry about, because the patient doesn’t want bad news, is not being compassionate. They are being negligent.
And the cost of that silence is tangible. I know people who came to the Church hungry for a word from God on this subject, found nothing, and eventually found their answers in the progressive cultural narrative — not because it was more convincing biblically, but because it was the only one willing to engage them at all. The Church’s silence was interpreted as either confusion or agreement. Neither served these people well.
The Way That Seems Right
Proverbs 16:25 in the Modern English Version reads: “There is a way that seems right to a man, but its end is the way of death.” I return to this verse often when I think about what the cultural conversation around sexuality has produced. The framework now dominant in Western culture — the one that says sexuality is purely a matter of personal identity, self-expression, and inner truth — has a destination. It leads somewhere. And the Church’s job, however uncomfortable it has become, is to point to a different road.
Not because the people on the wrong road are bad people. Not because they deserve judgment rather than help. But because the road goes somewhere, and it is not somewhere good, and love requires honesty about that. The parent who lets their child run into traffic rather than shout a warning, because shouting might upset them, is not a loving parent. The love that fails to warn is not love — it is cowardice wearing love’s clothes. One of the biggest gaps is the theology of wanting — what the Bible’s teaching on sexuality says about desire itself.
What Should Have Been Said
What should the Church have said? The truth, in love, clearly, with the same grace extended to those struggling with sexuality as to those struggling with anything else. This is the framework throughout the book I have written on this subject: the standard has not changed, and neither has the grace. Both things are true simultaneously, and they must be held together.
The standard — what the Bible says about human sexuality, about marriage, about the design God established from the beginning — is not negotiable and has not been repealed. The grace — the love of God for every person regardless of their history, their struggles, their current experience — is also not negotiable and has not been withdrawn. You do not get to choose one and abandon the other. The moment you separate them, you have lost the gospel.
Too many churches have tried to offer grace without truth, producing a shallow affirmation that helps no one. Others have tried to offer truth without grace, producing a cold condemnation that drives people away. The biblical model — the one Jesus himself demonstrated — is both, together, at the same time, with no apology for either.
Why I Am the One Writing This
Let me be transparent about something. I did not arrive at this subject from a position of academic detachment. My background includes things most people would rather not talk about — a family that practiced witchcraft, two suicide attempts, a darkness that I genuinely did not expect to survive. What changed everything for me was an encounter with God that was not theoretical. It was immediate, radical, and permanent. On Christmas Day, a depression that had sat over me like a stone was lifted, completely and without return.
I write about sexuality the way I write about everything else: from a position of rescue rather than perfection. I know what God can save a person from because God saved me. That experience is the basis for every word of this book. I am not standing at a distance, pointing at people whose struggles I have never understood. I am someone who found a way out of something most people thought was permanent, and I am doing my best to describe that way as clearly and as lovingly as I can.
The Church’s failure on sexuality has not been a failure of resources or intelligence. It has been a failure of courage and love — the courage to say what needs to be said, and the love that makes it worth saying. My prayer is that this book contributes something to correcting both.
Alan’s book confronts both failures of the Church head-on — the cruelty that drove people away and the silence that left them without answers. Get Sexuality →
