Alan FreemanMinistries International
Articles
›

The Role of the Church in Sexuality Conversations

What the local church owes its congregation — honest, loving, biblical teaching on sexuality.
Alan Freeman
·
·

I want to begin with a question that I think every church leader and every believer ought to sit with: if a person who has been deep in sexual confusion or bondage walked through the doors of your church this Sunday, what would they find? Would they find a place where the truth is spoken with enough courage to actually help them? Or would they find either cold condemnation that drives them away, or a warm affirmation that sends them deeper into bondage with a smile on the church’s face?

Because those are, in reality, the Church’s two failure modes when it comes to sexuality. Cruelty — condemnation without grace, rejection without relationship, truth without love. And cowardice — silence without truth, comfort without challenge, a pastor who will not say what the Word says because he is afraid of the response. Both of these failures are pastoral sins. And both of them leave real people without the one thing the Church uniquely possesses: the diagnosis and the cure together.

Chapters 4 and 13 of Sexuality address the Church’s role in this conversation from two different angles. Chapter 4 deals with the wolves — the false teachers who are openly promoting positions that contradict Scripture. Chapter 13 deals with the pastoral task — how to be a church where people find both genuine love and genuine truth.

The Two Failures — Cruelty and Cowardice

Let me be specific about the failure of cruelty first, because it is a real thing and it has caused real damage. There are people who grew up in churches where the teaching on sexuality was delivered with contempt — where the language used was designed to shame rather than to reach, where struggling people were treated as problems to be removed rather than souls to be loved. That is a betrayal of the pastoral calling. Jesus did not look at the woman caught in adultery with contempt. He looked at them with the eyes of God — who sees the full truth of a person’s situation and still reaches toward them.

The failure of cowardice is equally serious, and in the current cultural climate it may be more common. The cowardly church has a policy of avoidance — it will not say what Scripture says about sexuality because the cost feels too high. Jeremiah 6:14 is the prophetic diagnosis: “They have healed the wound of My people lightly, saying, ‘Peace, peace,’ when there is no peace.” The faithful prophet, at great personal cost, tells them what they need to hear. The Church that stays silent on sexuality in the name of peace is not being pastoral. It is being a false prophet.

Wolves in Wolves’ Clothing

Chapter 4 of the book deals with what I call wolves in wolves’ clothing — and I use that phrase deliberately, as distinct from the more familiar “wolves in sheep’s clothing.” What we are seeing in many Western denominations today is something different: teachers and leaders who are no longer hiding at all. They are openly, publicly, proudly advocating for the blessing of same-sex relationships. They are teaching that the biblical texts on sexuality have been misunderstood for two thousand years. They are celebrating what Scripture calls sin.

This is the apostasy that Paul warned of in 2 Timothy 4:3-4: “For the time will come when men will not endure sound doctrine, but they will gather to themselves teachers in accordance with their own desires, having itching ears, and they will turn their ears away from the truth and turn to myths.” That time is not coming. It is here. The faithful church must name this clearly.

The Homeless Shelter Analogy

In Chapter 13, I use an analogy that I think captures something important about the Church’s pastoral task. Think of a homeless shelter. Its doors are open — genuinely open — to anyone who needs help, regardless of where they have come from or what they have done. The love is real. The welcome is genuine. But the shelter has rules. You cannot come in drunk. You cannot bring in drugs. You cannot threaten the other residents. The boundaries are not the opposite of compassion — they are the framework within which compassion can actually function.

The Church is something like that. Its doors ought to be genuinely open — to people struggling with sexuality, to people coming out of same-sex relationships, to people who have been deep in sexual sin of every kind. The love must be real, not performative. But the Church also has a message: here is what God says, here is what freedom looks like, here is the help that is available. I said it in Chapter 13 and I will say it here: God loves you. Whoever you are. Whatever you have done. But God’s love for you also does not mean He is indifferent to whether you are walking in bondage or in freedom.

From Alan Freeman’s book Sexuality
Chapters 4 and 13 give church leaders and believers the framework to engage the sexuality conversation with both the courage of truth and the warmth of genuine love. Get Sexuality →

What the Church Must Say

Let me be specific about what the faithful church must be prepared to say, clearly and consistently.

It must say that sexual behavior outside the covenant of heterosexual marriage is sin — not because the Church has decided to be difficult, but because the Word of God says so. It must say it without contempt and without apology. It must say it as a doctor states a diagnosis — not with pleasure in the patient’s discomfort, but with the conviction that the diagnosis is the beginning of the path to healing.

It must say that transformation is real. The testimony of 1 Corinthians 6:11 — such were some of you — must be spoken from the pulpit. There are people who have been delivered from same-sex attraction, who have found genuine freedom, whose lives testify that the gospel does what it claims to do. Those testimonies must be part of the Church’s public conversation. Before the church can lead these conversations it must face why it has been too afraid to have them.

It must say that every person — regardless of what they are struggling with — is loved by God and within the reach of His grace. The same message that contains the hard truth about sin must also contain the extraordinary truth of grace. Both. Never one without the other.

The Church the World Needs

What I am describing is not an easy church to be. It requires courage to speak what the culture does not want to hear. It requires genuine love for people whom the Church has sometimes treated badly. It requires holding truth and grace together — not compromising either in the name of the other.

But that is the church that people who are genuinely struggling need. Not a church that tells them what the culture tells them — they can get that anywhere. A church that tells them the truth, loves them through the discomfort of it, and points them to a Jesus who is powerful enough to do something about it. That is the Church’s irreplaceable contribution to this conversation. And we must not abdicate it. When the church does this well, stories like this reader’s account of the Bible finally making sense about sexuality are the result.

Alan Freeman

Written by Alan Freeman

Pastor · Author · Bible Teacher — 40+ years in ministry

Alan Freeman is a UK-based pastor, speaker, and founder of Alan Freeman Ministries International, with more than 40 years in ministry. He pastored Christ Church 4U in Manchester for over a decade, and spent years on the front lines of ministry and social care — from the probation service to Salvation Army chaplaincy — walking with people through addiction, homelessness, and abuse. His straight-talking, Scripture-rooted teaching has built a community of more than 100,000 subscribers and over 700 videos on YouTube, and growing, and he is the author of five books on spiritual freedom, prayer, forgiveness, and biblical clarity. Read Alan’s story →

Go deeper

Sexuality

Biblical clarity, practical freedom, and a way back to God.