Alan FreemanMinistries International
Articles
›

The Biblical Case on Same-Sex Relationships

A careful, compassionate walk through what Scripture actually says — in context.
Alan Freeman
·
·

I want to be clear about what I am doing in this article — and what I am not doing. I am not interested in winning an argument. I am not interested in proving that people who disagree with me are bad people or malicious readers of Scripture. What I am interested in is establishing what the Bible actually says, because people who are making life-shaping decisions about identity and relationships deserve to know what they are working with. The revisionist arguments circulating in progressive Christianity — the arguments that the biblical texts either do not address same-sex relationships as we understand them today, or that they have been mistranslated, or that they apply only to exploitative contexts — are, on careful examination, not sustainable. I intend to show why, clearly and without cruelty.

The Old Testament Foundation

Leviticus 18:22 in the Modern English Version reads: “You shall not lie with a man as with a woman. It is an abomination.” The prohibition is explicit and unconditional. The immediate objection, which I have heard many times, is that this is part of the Levitical law code, and Christians do not follow all of that code — we eat shellfish, we wear mixed fabrics, we do not stone rebellious children. So why treat this verse as binding when we discard those?

The answer lies in understanding that not all Levitical law functions the same way. The food laws and purity regulations were ceremonial laws — signs of Israel’s distinctness as a people, pointing forward to the work of Christ. Jesus himself declared all foods clean in Mark 7:19. Peter’s vision in Acts 10 confirmed that the ceremonial distinctions between clean and unclean had been fulfillled and set aside. The sexual laws are different. They are moral laws — grounded not in Israel’s ceremonial distinctness but in the creation order of Genesis 1 and 2. They are consistent across both Testaments and affirmed by the New Testament authors.

Jude 7 in the Modern English Version confirms this: Sodom and Gomorrah “gave themselves over to sexual immorality and going after strange flesh.” The judgment on Sodom is not simply about inhospitality to strangers, as the revisionist reading suggests. Jude identifies it explicitly as sexual sin — “strange flesh,” going after what is outside the created order. The moral sexual law is carried forward into the New Testament precisely because it is rooted in creation, not in ceremony.

Paul’s Most Sustained Treatment

Romans 1:26-27 in the Modern English Version: “For this reason God gave them up to dishonorable passions. Even their women exchanged the natural use for what is against nature. Likewise, the men, leaving the natural use of the woman, burned in their lust for one another, men committing what is shameful with men and receiving in themselves the penalty of their error that was fitting.”

Paul is making a theological argument, not a cultural observation. He uses the phrase “against nature” — para physin in Greek — which means against the created order, against the design of Genesis 1 and 2. This is not a casual aside. Paul has been building a case from the beginning of Romans 1 about what happens when human beings suppress the knowledge of God: they exchange the Creator’s design for something of their own construction. Same-sex sexual practice is presented as one expression of that exchange.

The revisionist response is that Paul is describing the kind of exploitative, abusive, or coercive same-sex practice common in the Roman world — pederasty, prostitution, the use of slaves — and that this has nothing to do with loving, committed, equal same-sex relationships. But read the text again: Paul describes “burned in their lust for one another.” The language is mutual. It is the language of mutual desire, not exploitation. The revisionist reading does not survive a close engagement with what Paul actually wrote.

The Word Paul Coined

1 Corinthians 6:9-10 in the Modern English Version: “Do you not know that the unrighteous will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived. Neither the sexually immoral, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor male prostitutes, nor homosexuals, nor thieves, nor covetous, nor drunkards, nor revilers, nor extortioners will inherit the kingdom of God.”

The word translated “homosexuals” in this list is arsenokoitai — a compound word: arsen (male) and koitai (bed, to lie with). Paul appears to have coined it directly from the Greek translation of Leviticus 18:22, where the same two words appear in close proximity. Paul went back to the creation-order sexual law of Leviticus, took its language, and built a New Testament word from it. This is not accidental. Paul knew exactly what he was doing. He was demonstrating exegetical continuity between the Old Testament’s moral sexual law and his New Testament teaching. The claim that arsenokoitai only refers to exploitative or coercive same-sex acts has no lexical foundation. The word means what its components mean: a male who lies with a male.

Addressing the Revisionist Arguments Directly

Argument one: “Arsenokoitai only condemns exploitative homosexuality.” This argument claims that Paul’s word was specifically targeting abusive, coercive, or pederastic same-sex relationships, not committed adult same-sex partnerships. The problem is the word’s etymology. It is constructed directly from Leviticus 18:22, which contains no limitation to exploitation. The Levitical prohibition is categorical: a man shall not lie with a man as with a woman. There is no qualifier for consent or coercion in the Levitical text, and no basis for reading one into the word Paul built from it.

Argument two: “The Bible doesn’t address committed same-sex relationships.” This is the claim that the biblical authors simply never encountered what we would recognize as a loving, equal, committed same-sex relationship, and therefore their condemnations don’t apply to such relationships. Romans 1 refutes this directly. Paul describes mutual desire — people “burning in their lust for one another.” He is not describing exploitation or power imbalance. He is describing exactly the kind of mutual same-sex desire that forms the basis of the committed same-sex relationships this argument is trying to exempt from biblical criticism. The argument fails on its own terms.

Argument three: “Jesus never mentioned same-sex relationships.” The argument from Jesus’ silence is frequently deployed as though Jesus were constructing a comprehensive moral code and simply forgot to include this category. He was not. Jesus also never mentioned pedophilia, incest, or bestiality — presumably no one is arguing from that silence that he approved of them. When Jesus was asked directly about marriage and sexuality, he went to Genesis 1 and 2 and affirmed the creation design: male and female, one flesh, one man and one woman (Matthew 19:4-5). His silence on the specific form is not approval; his explicit affirmation of the design is.

The Grace in the Same Chapter

I cannot close this article without returning to 1 Corinthians 6:11: “And such were some of you. But you were washed, but you were sanctified, but you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus and by the Spirit of our God.”

The same chapter. The same hand. The same breath. The passage that contains the most explicit list of sexual sins in the New Testament also contains its most explicit statement of liberation from them. “Such were some of you” — past tense. The people Paul is writing to had been in those patterns. And they had been washed. Sanctified. Justified. The transformation was real. The freedom was real. The gospel Paul was delivering was not a set of prohibitions without provision — it was a declaration that the God who made the design also makes possible the return to it.

The biblical case is clear. And the grace within it is equally clear. That is not a contradiction. It is the whole point.

From Alan Freeman’s book Sexuality
Alan walks through every relevant passage on same-sex relationships in detail in his book — including answers to the revisionist arguments the Church has been too cautious to address. Get Sexuality →
Alan Freeman

Written by Alan Freeman

Pastor · Author · Bible Teacher — 40+ years in ministry

Alan Freeman is a UK-based pastor, speaker, and founder of Alan Freeman Ministries International, with more than 40 years in ministry. He pastored Christ Church 4U in Manchester for over a decade, and spent years on the front lines of ministry and social care — from the probation service to Salvation Army chaplaincy — walking with people through addiction, homelessness, and abuse. His straight-talking, Scripture-rooted teaching has built a community of more than 100,000 subscribers and over 700 videos on YouTube, and growing, and he is the author of five books on spiritual freedom, prayer, forgiveness, and biblical clarity. Read Alan’s story →

Go deeper

Sexuality

Biblical clarity, practical freedom, and a way back to God.