Someone told the Church it had to choose. Either hold the biblical position on sexuality — and be cruel, cold, judging, driving people away — or be compassionate, and quietly revise the position to make room for everyone. I have heard this presented as a genuine dilemma. I have watched thoughtful church leaders agonise over it as though it were a real binary. I want to say clearly: it is not. It is a false choice, and accepting it as real is a failure of both imagination and pastoral skill. Compassion and conviction are not opposites. The model for holding them together is Jesus himself, and he managed it without breaking a sweat.
The Model in John 8
The woman caught in adultery, recorded in John 8:1-11, is one of the most studied passages in the Gospels for exactly this reason. She was brought to Jesus by men who were using her situation to trap him. The law was clear — the penalty was death. They wanted to see whether he would uphold the law and lose his reputation for mercy, or show mercy and lose his claim to biblical faithfulness.
He did neither and both. He sent the accusers away with a single sentence that exposed their own moral standing. He did not stone her. He did not condemn her. When they had all gone, he looked at her and asked: “Does no one condemn you?” She said no. He said: “Neither do I condemn you.” And then — in the same breath, without pause, without softening — he said: “Go and sin no more.”
He did not call what she had done acceptable. He did not tell her that in the new dispensation of grace her adultery was fine. He told her she was not condemned, and then he told her to stop. Compassion and truth, simultaneously, from the same person, in the same moment. That is the model. It has always been available. The Church simply lost the nerve to use it.
The Wine Bottle in the Shelter
In Chapter 13 of my book, I use an analogy that I want to share here because I think it captures something important about the nature of genuine compassion.
Imagine a homeless shelter with a clear rule: no glass bottles. A well-meaning visitor arrives carrying a bottle of wine for a resident he knows. He argues: “But this is his wine. He wants it. I bought it for him.” The shelter manager says no. Firmly. The visitor presses: “But you’re supposed to be compassionate. This man is my friend.” The manager doesn’t move. Why? Not because the manager doesn’t care about the resident. Precisely because the manager does. Glass bottles in a shelter become weapons. They have before. The rule exists to protect the people in the shelter — including the resident this well-meaning visitor cares about.
Compassion that ignores the rule is not compassion. It is sentimentality. It feels generous in the moment. It causes harm later. Real compassion operates within an understanding of how things actually work — including how the patterns God has warned against actually damage people. The rules exist because the manager cares about the residents. The biblical boundaries around sexuality exist because God cares about human beings.
God Loves You. Whoever You Are.
This is my direct statement from Chapter 13, and I want to repeat it here because I mean it as plainly as it sounds: God loves you. Whoever you are. Whatever you have done. Whatever you have experienced. Whatever your history with the Church has been — whether you were embraced too warmly and told lies, or rejected too harshly and told only condemnation. God’s love for you is not contingent on any of it.
That is not a soft concession I am making to cultural pressure. It is my settled conviction, and it is what the Bible says. The door to God is not closed to anyone on the basis of their sexual history or current experience. The love of God is not a reward for the sexually tidy.
But love that is genuine does not leave people where it found them. The love of a good father does not look at his child walking toward a cliff and say: “I accept you completely, carry on.” It shouts. It pulls. It does whatever it takes to redirect. Not because the child is bad but because the father loves them too much to watch them fall.
What Real Love Does
1 Corinthians 13:6 in the Modern English Version says that love “does not rejoice in iniquity, but rejoices in the truth.” Real love is truth-bearing. It cannot celebrate what God calls harmful. It cannot affix its warm approval to a pattern of life that Scripture describes as contrary to creation design and damaging to the person living it. Affirmation without truth is not love. It is the emotional equivalent of a doctor who tells a patient their cancer is benign because they don’t want the patient to be upset. The short-term kindness causes long-term catastrophe.
I am aware that this is where some people will stop reading. The word “harmful” will feel like a judgment of people rather than a description of patterns. I want to be precise: I am not describing people as harmful. I am describing what Scripture describes — what the created design is for, and what happens when it is persistently departed from. People are not problems. They are persons. Every person experiencing same-sex attraction is a person of dignity and worth, loved by God, and not beyond the reach of his redemption. That is not in any tension with what I have just said. It is the same sentence.
The Challenge to Both Ends
Let me close with a direct word for both ends of this conversation.
If your version of biblical conviction on sexuality requires you to treat people struggling with same-sex attraction as less than fully human, as somehow beyond the ordinary reach of grace, as a problem to be managed or an agenda to be resisted rather than a person to be served — you have not arrived at biblical conviction. You have arrived at Pharisaism. The biblical position includes the full weight of what it demands, which is exactly why it must be delivered with the full love that makes it receivable. Half the gospel — truth without love — is a weapon, not a word from God.
And if your version of compassion requires you to affirm patterns of life that Scripture clearly describes as contrary to the creation design — if your love for people has led you to tell them things that are not true because the truth feels unkind — you have not arrived at compassion. You have arrived at the counterfeit of it. The kisses of an enemy are deceitful (Proverbs 27:6). The true friend says the hard thing because they care enough to say it. This balance is hardest at home — when someone you love is struggling with their sexuality, compassion and conviction must coexist.
Compassion without compromise is not only possible. It is the only version of either that deserves the name.
Alan’s book holds pastoral love and biblical truth together — refusing the false choice that has paralyzed the Church. Get Sexuality →
