Alan FreemanMinistries International
Articles
›

Answering the Top Objections to Tongues

"That was just for the early Church." "It's too emotional." Alan responds to the most common pushback.
Alan Freeman
·
·

I want to be clear before I begin: I held most of these objections myself. I am not writing from a distance, looking down on people who raise questions about tongues as though they are theologically naive or spiritually immature. I held them sincerely, for years. I reasoned through them carefully. I thought I had good grounds for my caution. And when I eventually returned to the text — not to the arguments about the text, but to the text itself — I found that my objections did not survive contact with Scripture. That is not a comfortable thing to admit. But it is the truth, and I think it is worth saying plainly.

Objection One: “The Gifts Ceased With the Apostles”

This is cessationism, and it has one fundamental problem: no Scripture teaches it. There is no verse — not one — that says the gift of tongues will cease when the apostles die, or when the canon of Scripture is complete. The argument is not exegetical. It is historical and experiential: the church largely stopped experiencing these gifts at some point, therefore they must have been withdrawn. That is an argument from church history, not from the Bible.

The only verse cessationists typically reach for is 1 Corinthians 13:10 — “when the perfect comes.” But read the very next verses. Verse 12: “For now we see only a reflection as in a mirror; but then face to face. Now I know in part; but then I shall know fully, even as I am fully known.” Face to face. Knowing fully as I am fully known. That is not describing a completed Bible. That is describing the return of Christ. The cessationist argument collapses when you examine the context of its own proof text.

And then there is Acts 2:39 NIV: “The promise is for you and your children and for all who are far off — for all whom the Lord our God will call.” No expiry date. No apostolic limitation. No clause restricting the promise to the first century. If you have been called, the promise is yours.

Objection Two: “It Is Just Gibberish”

1 Corinthians 14:2 NIV: “For anyone who speaks in a tongue does not speak to people but to God. Indeed, no one understands them; they utter mysteries by the Spirit.” Notice Paul’s framing. He does not say, “unfortunately, no one understands tongues.” He says tongues is directed to God, not to people. The incomprehensibility to human ears is not a defect — it is the design. Of course people cannot understand it. It is not intended for human comprehension. It is directed upward, not outward.

Objection Three: “I Tried It and Nothing Happened”

This objection is based on a category error. It assumes that spiritual activity is only real when it produces a felt emotional response. But Paul addresses this directly in 1 Corinthians 14:14 NIV: “For if I pray in a tongue, my spirit prays, but my mind is unfruitful.” The spirit prays regardless of whether the mind receives any information from the exchange. Feelings are not the measure of spiritual activity. Try again. This time, build on the Word rather than on your emotional register. Alan answers several of these objections on page one — the introduction to Your Heavenly Superpower takes them head-on.

From Alan Freeman’s book Your Heavenly Superpower
Your Heavenly Superpower works through every major objection with the same directness — and shows from Scripture why each one fails to hold its ground against the full weight of the New Testament text.
Get Your Heavenly Superpower →

Objection Four: “Not Everyone Speaks in Tongues”

This one requires a careful distinction that most people miss. Paul makes two distinct references to tongues in 1 Corinthians. In chapter 12, he discusses the public gift of tongues as one of several gifts distributed across the body — not given to every believer. First Corinthians 12:30 asks rhetorically: “Do all speak in tongues?” — and the answer, in that context, is no.

But in chapter 14, Paul is discussing the personal prayer language. And here his tone shifts markedly. First Corinthians 14:5 NIV: “I would like every one of you to speak in tongues.” This is Paul’s express desire for the entire church. Not a select few. Not the specially gifted. Every one of you. The private prayer language is available to every believer who asks for it.

Objection Five: “It Is Too Emotional — It Is Not for My Tradition”

I hear this from thoughtful people in Reformed, Anglican, and Baptist traditions, and I take the concern seriously. There is genuine discernment embedded in it — Charismatic culture has sometimes made tongues an emotional performance rather than a spiritual reality, and healthy believers rightly resist that. But resist the culture, not the gift.

The New Testament is the shared inheritance of every believer, regardless of tradition. What Paul taught in first-century Corinth is not the exclusive property of twentieth-century Pentecostalism. It belongs to the whole church. If Paul wanted every believer to speak in tongues — and verse 5 is clear that he did — then your tradition does not override that desire. Scripture interprets tradition; tradition does not interpret Scripture. The gift is available to you precisely where you are.

Alan Freeman

Written by Alan Freeman

Pastor · Author · Bible Teacher — 40+ years in ministry

Alan Freeman is a UK-based pastor, speaker, and founder of Alan Freeman Ministries International, with more than 40 years in ministry. He pastored Christ Church 4U in Manchester for over a decade, and spent years on the front lines of ministry and social care — from the probation service to Salvation Army chaplaincy — walking with people through addiction, homelessness, and abuse. His straight-talking, Scripture-rooted teaching has built a community of more than 100,000 subscribers and over 700 videos on YouTube, and growing, and he is the author of five books on spiritual freedom, prayer, forgiveness, and biblical clarity. Read Alan’s story →

Go deeper

Your Heavenly Superpower

Prayer was never meant to feel powerless.